Skip to main content

Table 3 ‘BIN Discordance Report’ analysis tool

From: Species identification of echinoderms from the North Sea by combining morphology and molecular data

Species BIN total member From our data set Highest rank of conflict BIN
Concordant Disconcordant
(After review)
Asteroidea
 Asterias rubens 61 35 Genus (X) IE X
 Leptasterias muelleri 14 6 Species   X T
 Stichastrella rosea 4 2   X  
 Astropecten irregularis 1 9 8 Species (X) D X
 Astropecten irregularis 2 29 27 Species (X) D X
 Luidia sarsii 18 15   X  
 Henricia sp. 1 19 1 Species   X T
 Henricia sp. 2 2 1   X  
 Anseropoda placenta 3 3   X  
 Hippasteria phrygiana 199 10 Order (X) IE X
 Porania pulvillus 7 1 Genus   X T
 Crossaster papposus 44 8   X  
 Solaster endeca 15 1   X  
Echinoidea      
 Gracilechinus acutus 25 13 Genus   X T
 Psammechinus miliaris 21 11 Family (X) IE X
 Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis 27 6 Species   X T
 Echinocyamus pusillus 8 1 Species   X T
 Brissopsis lyrifera 17 12   X  
 Echinocardium cordatum 21 14   X  
 Echinocardium flavescens 21 17   X  
 Spatangus purpureus 8 7   X  
Ophiuroidea      
 Asteronyx loveni 9 4   X  
 Amphipholis squamata 2 2   X  
 Amphiura chiajei 8 4   X  
 Amphiura filiformis 22 19   X  
 Ophiopholis aculeata 74 9   X  
 Ophiactis balli 8 1 Family   X T
 Ophiothrix fragilis 37 14   X  
 Ophiocten affinis 20 11 Family   X T
 Ophiura albida 19 15   X  
 Ophiura ophiura 37 29 Species (X) IE X
 Ophiura sarsii 17 1   X  
 Ophiura sarsii 11 6 Species (X) IE X
Holothuroidea
 Leptosynapta sp. 4 3 Genus   X T
 Thyone fusus 13 1 Genus   X T
  1. IE Identification error, T taxonomic problems, D designation